American Pie was established in May 2005 by the Miller family. This local, family-owned and operated business has grown to be an Outer Banks favorite. In fact, they were voted best pizza and ice cream in the Taste of the Beach! American pie sits on Highway 12 in Kill Devil Hills, just walking distance from many hotels, motels, cottages and of course the beach! The restaurant provides both indoor and outdoor dining.

Although American Pie prides itself with their one-of-a-kind pizza, they offer a variety of items on the menu. Whether it’s date night, family night or just snack time, American Pie is sure to meet your needs!

Hand-Tossed NY Style Pizza

Not all pizzas are created equal! Our pizzas are made from scratch with only the freshest ingredients.


Ice Cream & Smoothies

The Miller's have been making ice cream for more than 20 years. Their homemade ice cream became famous in 1988 in a restaurant named Fast Eddie's.


Coupons & Delivery

Everything tastes better delivered with a deal!